The Ice Cream Cake & Pie Shop

For your convenience, we have a selection of Grab & Go cake sizes and pies always available. To see what is currently in stock, just visit our easy-to-use online ordering system and view the Cake & Pie Shop section. Or better yet, stop by and see us!

​

Our Grab & Go Carnival Cake is a classic favorite of chocolate ice cream, with a cookie crunch middle layer, vanilla ice cream, and topped with our heavenly whip cream frosting. 

 

Standard birthday cake candles and numbered candles are also available for purchase. Make us your one-stop birthday shop and give a gift of tasty with a Dairy Carnival Gift Card!

 

Available Cake Sizes: 9", or 10"

Price:$28.49/$31.99

At the Ice Cream Cake & Pie Shop, we have a wide variety of cake choices to please your palate. From chocolate to mint to peanut butter to coffee, flavors for everyone! In as little as 24 hours notice, have your cake and eat it too! *48-72 hours pre-order is preferred

 

Available sizes: 8", 9", 10" or 12"

Cake price: $29.99, $31.49, $34.99, $39.99
 

Pre-order Holiday Flavors Custom Cake:

Eggnog - Gingerbread - Peppermint Stick 

 

Standard Pre-order Custom Cake List:

Birthday Party - Brownie Bliss - Chocolate Oreo

 Coffee Mocha - Cookies & Cream -

Cookie Dough Crazy - Mint Chocolate Chip -

Mint Cookie Crunch - Oreo Vanilla -

Peanut Butter & Chocolate - 

Peanut Butter & Vanilla - Peanut Butter Craze 

Raspberry Crumble - Sea-salt Caramel Truffle - Strawberry Shortcake - Tiramisu

*flavor substitutions may be available

​

If you can dream it, we can make it! We carry a wide selection of flavors and toppings for you to choose from. We can use up to three different ice cream flavors in one cake! Don't see what you are looking for? Then please contact us and we will see if a special order can be placed.

​

Current Ice Cream Flavors

Blackberry Cheesecake, Brownie Batter, Butter Pecan, Butter Cookie, Sea-Salt Caramel, Chocolate, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Dark Chocolate with Raspberry, Coffee, Cookie Dough, Cotton Candy,

Maple Walnut, Mint Chocolate Chip, Mint Cookie, Peanut Butter Craze, Pistachio, Pumpkin Cheesecake, Raspberry Fudge, Strawberry, Vanilla

Current Toppings

Andes Mint, Banana Slices, Black Raspberry, Blueberry, Brownie Bites, Butterfinger, Butterscotch, Caramel, Cheesecake Pieces, Cherries,

Wild Cherry Topping, Chocolate Syrup,

Cinnamon-Sugar, Chocolate Cookie Crunch,

Vanilla Cookie Crunch, Cookie Dirt, Cookie Dough,

Graham Crackers, Gummy Worms, Heath, M&Ms, Marshmallow Topping, Mini Cocoa Marshmallows,

Mint Syrup, Nerds, Chopped Nuts, Chopped Oreos,

Chopped Peanut Butter Cups, Peanut Butter, Pineapple, Pop Rocks, Pumpkin Spice,

Red Raspberry, Reese's PB Butter Cups, 

Reese's Pieces, Strawberry, Wet Walnuts

Sprinkles - Chocolate or Rainbow

​

Not your average pie... our ice cream pies are made with a graham cracker pie shell, filled with premium ice cream, and topped with delicious dessert sauce &  whipped creme. Indulge your cravings for only $15.99. Just browse our pre-order pie menu and contact us at 518-868-4158 to place your order. 

 

​Are you looking to create your own ice cream pie flavor? We can make almost any custom pie with our ice cream and toppings from our Customer Creation list (additional costs may apply). Please contact us for more information.

Pre-order Ice Cream Pie Menu

Eggnog

Gingerbread

Peppermint Stick

Blueberry

Butter Cookie

Chocolate Cream

Chocolate Crunch

Coffee Mocha

Cookies & Cream

Cookie Dough

Mint Chocolate Chip

Mint Cookie Crunch

Oreo (Chocolate or Vanilla)

Peanut Butter

Red Velvet

Sea-salt Caramel

Strawberries & Cream

Vanilla Crunch